New England Law | Boston

Return to the New England Law | Boston home page.
Center for Law and Social Responsibility
New England Law Opportunities
Center for Law and Social Responsibility Environmental Advocacy Project Criminal Justice Project Education Law Project Immigration Law Project Public Service Project Women's and Children's Advocacy Project Student International Experiences

Welcome to the CLSR Weblog.

Please browse around, catch up on our latest public interest law projects, peruse our links (including the one to our home site, New England Law | Boston), and add your comments. Before you start, we encourage you to become familiar with our Terms of Use.

Showing posts with label Students. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Students. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Student Opportunity: Street Law Clinic Coordinator

WORK STUDY OPENING
STREET LAW CLINIC COORDINATOR
Law student members of the National Lawyers Guild, Massachusetts Chapter, have conceptualized, created, and run an educational project, Street Law Clinic, which offers workshops for the working class and the poor with essential information about law and law enforcement.
Presently the Project offers seven clinics: 4th Amendment Rights (Stop & Search), Tenant/Landlord Disputes, Civil Disobedience Defense, Immigration Law, Bankruptcy Law/Consumer Protection, Foreclosure & Eviction Prevention, and Workers’ Rights. The clinics are conducted for community organizations, schools, shelters, and unions.

QUALIFICATIONS:
- 1st or 2nd year WORK-STUDY LAW STUDENT;
- very good organizational skills;
- knowledge of Spanish helpful but not required.

RESPONSIBILITIES:
- work 10 hours/week minimum;
- schedule training sessions at local law schools at the beginning of each semester;
- contact community groups and schedule clinics;
- line up attorneys and law students to conduct each clinic.


For more information on how to apply please visit CSO Symplicity Site Job ID 7264. To learn more about the Guild and our political work, please visit www.nlgmass.org.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

Discovering Justice Information Session October 6th

Discovering Justice

Thursday, October 6th, from 3-4 pm in Room 301 students are invited to come learn about Discovering Justice and ways to get involved.

http://www.discoveringjustice.org/ Projects include:

· Children Discovering Justice: This program is designed for 1st and 2nd grade students to take a field trip to the courthouse and learn about how the legal system works. They first take a quick tour of the building, and then we bring them to a courtroom where they preside over their own case (usually an issue like a stolen teddy bear). Law students would volunteer to help these students formulate their arguments and generally oversee the case (though we have a staff member who will be leading the program). It typically lasts for about 40 minutes.

· Kids Courts and Citizenship: In this program, the students act as a jury while our volunteers take the roles as defense and prosecutor in a case. After hearing the arguments of the volunteers, the students deliberate and make a decision as a jury would. We are hoping to have attorneys for this since it is helpful for them to talk about what they do as a lawyer, but there may be some room for law students if they are particularly interested.

· Discovering the Bill of Rights: Here we recreate a famous case (typically Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District) and help the kids work through it from a legal perspective. Law students would be helpful in coaching smaller groups of kids to help them understand how trials take place and why the rights provided to us are so important.

New England Law| Boston's NLG and ACS Speaker Event

On Wednesday October 5th New England's National Lawyers Guild and American Constitution Society will be holding a speaker event about what is required of states under the Sixth and Fourteenth amendments in regard to indigent defense services and how states avoid their constitutional responsibilities. The featured speaker is David Carroll, Director of Research for the National Legal Aid & Defender Association The event will take place at 5:30 p.m. in room 506 and food will be served from Boston Kitchen Pizza.


Some background information on this event:

In Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335 (1963), the United States Supreme Court deemed the right to attorney for those unable to afford one “fundamental and essential” to fair trials. Nearly 50 years later, public defense services in America are plagued by deep-rooted, chronic problems that our nation’s top law enforcement official, U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder, has called “morally untenable” and “economically unsustainable.” The American Bar Association (ABA) defines the ability of states to guarantee a poor defendant constitutionally-adequate legal representation as being in a perpetual “state of crisis.” And, since upwards of 85% of all people charged with state crimes with potential jail time qualify for a public lawyer, state and local governments daily jeopardize the ability of our courts to produce verdicts that are fair, correct, swift and final.

Thursday, June 23, 2011

Hello again, from Kathmandu, Nepal

As I sit down to write about my experiences, I cannot decide where I should begin. There are so many events I want to talk about that my outline for this blog itself is becoming a blog.

Looking for a needle in a haystack (the struggle to locate a case precedent)

Previously, I had mentioned that I was buried in stacks of books locating case precedents. To my awe, I found out that these reported cases are just a few of the cases from the Supreme Court which are selected as important cases by a committee (still awestruck as to what really is the committee’s basis for the selection of cases). However, there are many cases which remain unreported and the only way to find them is by networking. Even with networking, it is impossible if one is not aware of the decision number, party name or date decided and yet, here we are just talking about Supreme Court cases. The district court or appellate court’s precedents are near to impossible to locate. More and more, I am starting to believe that my possibility of getting on-board a flight to the moon might be better possibility than locating these cases. I feel like I am Nancy Drew trying to solve a mystery. Now! Really? Does it really have to be that hard to locate cases?

But, there is definitely light at the end of the tunnel. I found two Supreme Court cases which admitted that the defendants were victims of Battered Woman Syndrome (BWS). Even though the court’s mention of BWS is literally two sentences which are the definition of BWS in English, then the translation in Nepali. So now, I am unsure if it is still considered as two sentences. The defendants were found guilty but received reduced sentences because they were victims of BWS. At least, these cases are some basis for me to further explore so that I can write a suggestive and persuasive memorandum advocating recognition of such defenses.

The value of life according to ……..

The inequality in terms of number of years to be served by defendants of different genders who committed similar crimes behind bars somehow is shocking even though I should have expected this. There is a hierarchy in value of life. The most valuable are men, a little less valuable are women and the least valuable are children. After reading so many precedents, I discovered a common trend. I can almost create a nice, colorful and pretty pie chart to demonstrate the significant difference in value of life amongst the three classes of human race; the only problem is that the numbers are nowhere near being nice, colorful or pretty. Simple illustrations:

1. Murder of MAN: Wife killing husband in a fight (provocation by husband) gets 15 years even though the murder was almost accidental. Here are the fascinating sets of facts. Husband tries to hit wife with a log of wood while quarrelling. Wife snatches the log and hits the husband with the log. Husband sustains a head injury, denies seeking medical treatment and dies after twelve days due to the injury being infected.

2. Murder of WOMAN: Husband killing wife and staging it as a suicide gets 9 years imprisonment.

3. Murder of CHILD: Women killing their new born child (infanticide) get 2 to 5 years imprisonment. For some reason there are so many of those infanticide cases in the Nepal Supreme Court precedent. It almost looks as if these are the only types of cases NSC is interested in deciding.

The need to protect the most vulnerable (Children) is almost nonexistent.

My mid way

My midway to the weeks of my internship is fast approaching. My days here have been somewhat entertaining in ways one cannot even imagine. In the past three weeks, I have managed to slip and fall on a banana peel in the middle of a major street on my way back from work. Too bad I cannot file a slip and fall TORTS claim. No broken bones, just slightly bruised knees and arms but have since healed. Thanks to the scarce supply of water, I managed to get my first food poisoning since my arrival two days ago. Yet, I find these experiences amusing and simply refreshing. They are priceless experiences because they make me realize how much we take our lives for granted back in the United States. It is a win, win situation because I am learning about law and life at the same time.

I am happy to report that my researches are finally coming together and the outline for my memorandum is almost ready.

Follow-up on the District Court

For those of you who wanted to know what happened to those shackled kids charged with possession, use and selling of illegal narcotics, I am happy to report that they were set free on bail. The bail amount was very small. All thanks to the well trained ILF-Nepal defense attorney for he presented a very compelling argument backed with evidence. The case is far from being over but at least, these kids are free from the unruly detention centers.

My ending note

I think I have written enough for two weeks. I will report back in a fortnight, hopefully with a more enlightening, entertaining and engaging blog.

Rina Gurung

Kathmandu, Nepal

Monday, June 6, 2011

Hello from Kathmandu, Nepal


Seized stolen properties collecting dust

Temporary Jail in Kathmandu District Court


Record Room

Settlement Room

Flag of Nepal in the center of Kathmandu District Court

Hello, I am an up-an-coming second year law student from the New England Law | Boston. I was offered an opportunity for a summer legal internship with the International Legal Foundation (ILF) in Nepal. ILF is a 501(c) (3) not-for-profit organization and it provides free quality criminal defense services to the poor in post-conflict, transitional countries. Thanks to today’s advancement in technology, my interview was conducted via Skype.

I was able to accept this offer with the help of the Center for Law and Social Responsibility at the NEL|B. Special thanks to Prof. Dina F. Haynes and Ms. Martha Drane, Fellow (CLSR) for their endless efforts to ensure that I obtain this opportunity.

Sharpening my LRW Skills

My internship started on May 30, 2011. While most Americans were celebrating Memorial Day and grilling barbeques, I was buried in a large pile of books that I had to digest in order to understand the aspects of criminal law in Nepal. My first task was to research precedents by the Nepal Supreme Court to write memorandum regarding Nepal Court Management Rule 188. It had been ages since I read materials in Nepali (the national language) and, to add to my misery, a Supreme Court decision is a far cry from the short sentences I was used to reading in Nepali a decade ago. However, I managed to be mentally prepared in researching and reading case precedents. To my greatest disadvantage, none of the materials are found online. I had left behind the world of LexisNexis and Westlaw the minute I took off from JFK Airport in New York. Hence, I started my research by digging the books from the ILF Library and going through the indexes of each book in anticipation that the cases used Rule 188.

Rule 188 is a provision in the General Code of Nepal which gives the presiding judge the power to make a discretionary judgment, in terms of reducing punishment penalties based on the circumventing circumstances at the time of crime. It was a moment of awakening to read so many Supreme Court opinions and discover that none of the opinions ever cited a single precedent. The law here is studied by learning statutes and codes, unlike in the United States where the law is learned from cases. A practice such as this in Nepal has led to major discrepancies in the way codes and statutes are interpreted. The courts do not pay much attention to how a previous case with similar facts was decided. This reality demonstrates that, to a certain extent, law in the United States is consistent. Here, it is up to the judge to find the argument by either side plausible.

I am currently working on cases that might help the court recognize certain defenses. Defendants charged with crime, who suffer from psychiatric problems such as insanity or psychiatric trauma such as battered woman syndrome, are often indicted. The courts are very reluctant to accept excuse/justification defense. My work hopefully will help the courts change their direction for the better.

I will further update everyone on these developments in the coming weeks.

Visit to the District Court

For those of us who complain about the courts system in the United States, please visit Nepal and observe a day in court; then, our opinion might alter drastically.

I observed a jail bail argument for defendants who were charged with possession and selling of illegal narcotic substances. The charged defendants were virtually kids who were picked up by the police from the streets and were simply in the wrong place at the wrong time. They were on the lucky side of the system because their jail bail court day was set two months after they were arrested. There are many instances where arrested individuals have to wait months or even years just to find themselves in the court for the first time after their arrest.

Innocents are trapped for months if not years in jail due to corrupt law enforcement agents (police), a broken court system (law, lawyers, and judges) and political turmoil (the continuous struggle to write a new constitution for two years and counting).

My one day in court confirmed my idea to knowledge that, in Nepal, only the helpless poor get arrested for petty crime while the police and courts salute the major criminals who are always the rich and powerful.

Rina Gurung

Kathmandu, Nepal

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Coping Strategies

Greetings from Nairobi! I want to apologize for my delay in blog posts. I have spent the better part of my last three weeks fully involved in interviews as well as trying to see as much of the country as possible. I want to reiterate my thanks to the Center of Law and Social Responsibility for giving me this amazing opportunity.

For the past three weeks, I have spent a good deal of time considering coping mechanisms. The first year of law school taught me how to manage a number of different problems: the Socratic Method, preparation for quizzes, and handling the stress of finals. However, the Center for Law and Social Responsibility guides students to use their education to help those less fortunate. In the course of that work, many students will find that our destitute clients have few happy stories, just hopes for happy endings. The question becomes how, as lawyers, we accomplish our tasks without being overcome by the stories we hear on a day-to-day basis.

While working at Mapendo, I have found this question to be a daily challenge. Since beginning my interviews I have had clients from the Congo, Rwanda, Ethiopia, and Somalia. Refugees in the African continent have unique stories of suffering often displaying what my father would call “man’s inhumanity to man.” I naively thought that I could handle the flood of stories coming through my office each day by separating work and home. Yet, I’ve found that listening to stories of abuse, separation, forced immigration, rape, murder, and genocide are not stories that you can detach from your own psyche and emotions.

Before I started working for Mapendo, I had a discussion with a friend in a similar kind of work. He brought up the issue of coping with refugees’ stories, and discussed his failure to manage those emotions in a suitable way. My friend told me that, to his own dismay, he separated refugees from himself. He could not listen to a refugee boy detail the rape and murder of his mother and associate that story with his own family. For him, separating himself from refugees was a survival method – a coping technique.

I left that conversation with an uneasy feeling. I felt that separating myself from my clients was exactly what I wasn’t supposed to do. At the same time I began to understand the awesome gravity that these stories held. I made a promise to attempt to not separate myself, but I was cognizant that I needed to develop a suitable coping method quickly.

In one of my recent interviews, a Somali woman, who had lost two of her children in a rocket grenade strike, succinctly explained the feeling that most refugees express in their interviews, albeit in different ways. She said that “you lose hope before you are even dead.” After hearing quotes like this, I’ll admit, my coping method is not foolproof. Yet, what I’ve found is an almost constant underlying theme of refugees’ stories is a random act of kindness. Without a doubt the original story is one of abject cruelty, but the difference between a person who is sitting in my office and a person who passed away in the country of origin is often one single act by a stranger. In this Somali woman’s case, a Somali man led her out of the warzone, where he then paid a driver to transport the woman to the Somali –Kenyan border. At the border, the local Somali community assisted the woman in crossing into Kenya.

In no way am I suggesting that these random acts of kindness absolve what has come before them, and certainly I acknowledge my inability to truly identify with a mother of two. As for now, I guess my coping method, of finding a silver lining in each story, works because I want to find a silver lining. I don’t want to lose hope in the populations I serve or the world at large. Perhaps it’s idealism to an extreme or just youthful naiveté, but for me, for now, it works.

Monday, June 21, 2010

Learning the Frosty Fundamentals

Once again, greetings from Kenya! As the east coast enjoys / curses the summer heat, I am sitting in seventy degree, sunny weather. Oh, the majesty of the southern hemisphere in June!

Starting on the 14th, I began to assume my day-to-day responsibilities at Mapendo International (for full details regarding the organization, please see the June 17th posting). Basically, I will be interviewing at-risk urban refugees to determine whether Mapendo can offer possible assistance. On Monday and Tuesday I was allowed to observe my colleagues to learn the dos and don’ts of the interviewing process. Like me, both of my co-workers have legal backgrounds. Prior to this week, I don’t believe I comprehended the full extent of skills I gained in the past year of studying the law. An avid reader, I took no joy in much of my courses’ required reading. I could easily have done without the nights of trying to determine the holdings for late 19th century cases.

Unbeknownst to me at the time, my professors were teaching me to clear away the excess material to locate the one essential principal of the opinion. As I sat in my colleagues’ offices, I realized these same skills were being utilized in their interviewing process. Each co-worker started with the simple request that the client tell their story of escape. My colleagues rarely spoke, but when they did it was to re-focus the narrative – an attempt to concentrate on the one defining criteria that each refugee’s story must fulfill in order to obtain aid.

Like the 19th century opinions, these interviews can sometimes be maddening. As Justice Scalia once noted, the “law pronounced … must be principled, rational, and based upon reasoned distinctions.” Vieth v. Jubelirer, 541 U.S. 267, 278 (2004). Yet, a refugee’s story is often devoid of any type of rationality or logic. A refugee sees a senseless murder as a senseless murder. Whereas my legal criteria demands I determine whether this killing justifies, to my current client, a well-founded fear of persecution based upon her race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion.

I have found this dichotomy between my refugees’ emotional tales and the necessity for me to ask cold and calculating questions difficult. I understand that a cold evaluation ensures the interviewer’s judgment is not clouded by emotions, and that the law is utilized in a manner which Justice Scalia would approve. Yet, I hope with time I am able to find a proper balance between interviewing objectively while providing a warm and compassionate environment. After watching my colleagues, I gained many methods I would like to emulate, perhaps none more important than trying to foster a safe environment, if not a friendly one. In the end, I hope that my worth is determined by how I use the law, and not necessarily my sunny (or lack thereof) disposition.

Best,

Jerry

Thursday, June 17, 2010

Greetings from Nairobi, Kenya

My name is Jerry Donahue. I am a rising 2nd year student at New England Law Boston. Through the assistance of the administration and faculty, I was able to obtain an internship in Nairobi working for a refugee assistance program. I would especially like to thank Ms. Adonia Simpson, the Center for Law and Social Responsibility’s Fellow, and the Director of New England’s Immigration Project, Associate Professor of Law Ms. Dina Haynes.

In early fall, the Center for Law and Social Responsibility offered the opportunity to interview for an internship working with refugees in Kenya. I came to New England Law after living for a year in Phoenix, Arizona where I worked with newly arrived refugees from countries spanning the globe. The Center’s position was possibly the only internship the school could have offered that I was uniquely qualified. After first interviewing with Ms. Simpson and Professor Haynes, I moved on to an application with Mapendo International.

Sasha Chanoff started Mapendo International about five years ago. The organization’s mission is to provide assistance to refugees who have fallen through the cracks of humanitarian assistance, most notably in urban populations. In those five years, the program has acquired a crystal reputation in the humanitarian assistance world for its medical assistance, community service, and protection programs for at-risk refugees. Through the help of Ms. Simpson and Ms. Haynes, I was able to survive the interviewing process and obtain the Kenyan internship with Mapendo. On June 4th, I said goodbye to my family and friends and headed off for an African adventure.

I arrived in Nairobi after over a day of travel (for the record, KLM Royal Dutch Airlines rock). Mapendo had a driver waiting for me at the airport and he promptly dropped me off at the organization’s apartment. Mapendo staff were there to greet me upon my arrival. I started work on Monday. To be sure, my experience in Phoenix provided me with more requisite knowledge on refugees than the average bear. However, I spent the better part of the first week knee deep in reading materials regarding the situations of refugees across the continent – from reasons forcing refugees flight from their home countries to the effect the refugee populations are having on host countries like Kenya. On Tuesday and Thursday, I went with Mapendo’s outreach team to refugee havens in Nairobi. We met with families in their homes, usually little more than a 12 x 8 room with 2 to 8 people living inside. We heard stories of harassment, hunger, serious medical ailments, assault, rape, and murder.

On Monday (the 14th of June), I will begin my day-to-day duties of interviewing and assessing at risk refugees to ascertain whether they are suitable for possible protection through Mapendo. I have no doubt that the stories will be the likes of which New England Law Boston students can little imagine, let alone cope with. Yet, as of now, I am ready for the challenge.

In the coming weeks I will detail my experiences throughout my African adventure. Please check in periodically and if you have any questions or comments, please send me a shout.

Best,

Jerry Donahue